Cowards
By Arnold Alamon
Wrapped in Grey
Thursday, July 4, 2013
A SOCIAL debate is now raging and it is one whose terms are unclarified to allow for productive discourse. It is an unfortunate debate but timely nevertheless because it reveals particular class dispositions in the context of elite rule.
Social media has been in an uproar recently over the benefits that informal settlers are set to receive from government over the plan to relocate them to government housing complexes at the outskirts of Metro Manila.
What irks what I presume to be middle class netizens are the cash assistance and ready housing that await what they refer to as squatters.
Much chest-beating is currently being done in posts and status messages about their tax-paying capacities in contrast to the supposed mendicancy of the poor.
Why is it then that these lazy good-for-nothings should receive housing assistance, they cry, when they productive citizens who have contributed so much more to government coffers could barely pay the rent, travel two hours to and from their place of work every day, and still cannot fully pay the smartphone on credit card loan on which they posted their classist rants.
What bothers me with this arrogance is that instead of commiserating with the plight of the poor living on top of danger zones, waiting to be washed out to sea when the next deluge comes, they see their own pathetic material inadequacies.
Instead of viewing these communities such as the one in North Triangle as homes of families and children, they would rather amplify their own entitlements towards their dream middle class lifestyles and how, despite their best efforts, these remain out of reach.
Even more scandalous is that many of these social climbers lived and survived in these typed of spaces. They acquired their education which enabled them to work in places like Makati, Ortigas, or Eastwood but while in college, they relied on Manang Aristocart to provide for their meals, or Manong Boy for their fifth-hand textbook, or Lola Maria for their cheap laundry.
Till now, they still depend on the workers of the informal economy to provide for their inexpensive goods and services so that they can afford their rock-and-roll lifestyle. You want your load for your pre-paid phone, go to Manang Janitor. Your saving up for a big date, have your meals delivered on the cheap by Manang Nene. And yet they regard them with such disdain and wouldn’t care less if the Manangs’ and Manongs’ homes of 30 years are demolished.
And the argument that they live on land that is not their own and should therefore be driven away like dogs is problematic. Many of these areas that are now under threat of demolition were appropriated by government by legal fiat.
If you do your research, there are families in these areas that have been there since the turn of the century. Besides, I still bristle at the idea that we regard our fellow Filipinos as squatters without hesitation. Yet some even have the temerity to complain, particularly BPO workers, that we are not giving enough ownership rights to foreign investors, their patrons.
The middle class should not feel neglected just because government is offering concessions for urban poor communities that are to be demolished. The real politics behind the cash assistance and the offer of government housing is not an enlightened political response to urban blight but a tactic for hastening the real-estate development projects where more of these over-worked, underpaid, wanna-be middle class workers like them will be employed.
The truth is, there is a lot more in common between the middle class and the urban poor in an economy in crisis. It would just take a declaration of redundancy or merger from corporate headquarters in New York for them to find themselves living among the squatters they so hate.
The difference between the two is while the middle class is quick to cower in fear over the potential threat to their precarious livelihoods and therefore accept the low pay, long working hours, and absence of job security; the poor, in contrast, have nothing to lose. That is why they have resorted to defending their communities, setting up barricades, and matching the violence of the State with their own against these threats of demolition of their homes.
Whatever benefits they will receive is justified because they earned these with their collective courage. I cannot say the same for the cowards.
Published in the Sun.Star Cagayan de Oro newspaper on July 04, 2013. #